AmericanFamily’s recent postings on her family’s schooling dilemmas have gotten me thinking about my own 4.5 year old and his own upcoming schooling (and my own dilemmas). The story thus far, for those who haven’t been playing along at home, is that I initially planned to homeschool my boys. Not because I want them protected from the evil sinful world that is public education, but because I hated my own schooling, was immensely bored by it, and feel like it sucked any love of learning right out of me, something that I’m only beginning to recover from at age 30. I love the thought of creating a learning environment for my boys where they get to take the reins, where they get to determine what they learn and I am merely the facilitator, the one doing mad google searches to find endless resources with which to encourage their learning processes.
But alas, my work schedule (and the fact that I have to work at all) is not likely to allow such a venture. And in all honesty, while I like (love) the thought of homeschooling my boys, I’m a little afraid that the actual doing of it might exceed my…dedication? I’m definitely more of a low maintenance parent and I worry that such intensive involvement might actually be beyond me…at least while they’re little.
My more recent thinking directed me toward public school until they’re 12, at which point they’d be old enough to stay home alone, at which point I could pull them out of school and then set them up with some largely self-directed homeschooling, with my assistance available on evenings and weekends. Although this might sounds a little too unsupervised for some, I think that with some reasonable guidelines and expectations, as well as a good number of resources at their disposal, this could actually be very good for them in terms of fostering independence and responsibility for their own outcomes.
As my four year old approaches school age I’ve been thinking about school on and off but I didn’t really start thinking about it directly until my ex requested custody of him so that he could expose him to a supposedly better public schooling system. I was caught off guard with the whole topic and had to catch up quickly. I naively hoped that my ex might be willing to consider private school but since his primary argument for taking our son was based on a supposedly superior public school district, he refused, so I stopped even thinking about anything other than public schooling.
I’ve never felt entirely comfortable with this decision but I figured that there are a wide enough range of public schools in my urban setting that surely I can find something that will be a good fit and that won’t squelch him too much and that will provide adequate resources for a child who, if genetics hold, is likely to need more of a challenge than the “average” student. But the more I look at the schools and the more I learn about public schooling in general, the much less comfortable I feel. Right now he’s enrolled to begin Head Start in the fall (because it’s free and his dad wants him in a preschool setting…and I’m fine with that) but I can’t shake the unpleasant feeling that Head Start exists not only to help certain kids prepare for kindergarten by giving them a leg up, but it also serves to squish down those square pegs who might not otherwise fit into the round hole of public education.
My four year old is a smart kid, but he’s also very active and very inquisitive. I can’t even remotely kid myself that any teacher trying to manage at least twenty other kids is going to take the time to answer his millions of questions, even if s/he wanted to. I can’t imagine it’s going to be okay for him to bounce around the classroom, flitting from one task to another as his interest is flagged by something new. And the worst part is that the only option in terms of managing a classroom that is likely to have more than one bright, energetic, inquisitive four year old is to find some way to get them to sit down and shut up. At the very worst he will be labeled a problem child if he won’t. The thought of my four year old learning that he is wrong to ask questions and explore makes me feel ill.
So I’ve decided that regardless of what my ex wants, I’m putting private school back on the table. This fall I’ll be researching them all, taking many school tours and ultimately figuring out what will be the best match, and if that turns out to be a private school, so be it. And if I have to find a way to pay for every penny myself, well so be that too (luckily I will qualify for plenty of financial aid, so I don’t anticipate that tuition will cost much more than what I currently pay for daycare).
In terms of next year, I think I’ve found a nice Montessori program to supplant Head Start as a good place to stash my four year old until I manage to wend my way through the larger education maze. It’s reasonably priced and although it’s even farther away than my daycare (where my one year old would continue to reside), it’s not too far from said daycare, so it wouldn’t be too much trouble to drop off one, then the other, then hop on my bus to work. Of course, “reasonably priced” means that it’s going to cost well over twice what I currently pay…and that’s assuming his dad is willing to kick in his half too. But overall I think it will be worth the investment. According to his dad (who is, admittedly, a less than trustworthy source, our four year old loves his current Montessori program and I can’t say that he feels similarly for his daycare.